Yes, the situation does say the bomb is there. But it also says the bomb isn’t there if you Left-box.
At the very least, this is a contradiction, which makes the scenario incoherent nonsense.
(I don’t think it’s actually true that “it also says the bomb isn’t there if you Left-box”—but if it did say that, then the scenario would be inconsistent, and thus impossible to interpret.)
At the very least, this is a contradiction, which makes the scenario incoherent nonsense.
(I don’t think it’s actually true that “it also says the bomb isn’t there if you Left-box”—but if it did say that, then the scenario would be inconsistent, and thus impossible to interpret.)
That’s what I’ve been saying to you: a contradiction.
And there are two ways to resolve it.