In particular, I think it’s a bit harsh to solely apply the [genuinely new directions discovered] metric. Even when doing everything right, I expect the hit rate to be very low there, with [variation on current framing/approach] being the most common type of success.
Mhm. In fact I’d want to apply a bar that’s even lower, or at least different: [the extent to which the participants (as judged by more established alignment thinkers) seem to be well on the way to developing new promising directions—e.g. being relentlessly resourceful including at the meta-level; having both appropriate Babble and appropriate Prune; not shying away from the hard parts].
the setup were flexible enough that it didn’t seem likely to limit the potential of participants (by being less productive-in-the-sense-desired than counterfactual environments).
Agree that this is an issue, but I think it can be addressed—certainly at least well enough that there’d be worthwhile value-of-info in running such a thing.
I’d be happy to contribute a bit of effort, if someone else is taking the lead. I think most of my efforts will be directed elsewhere, but for example I’d be happy to think through what such a program should look like; help write justificatory parts of grant applications; and maybe mentor / similar.
Ah thanks!
Mhm. In fact I’d want to apply a bar that’s even lower, or at least different: [the extent to which the participants (as judged by more established alignment thinkers) seem to be well on the way to developing new promising directions—e.g. being relentlessly resourceful including at the meta-level; having both appropriate Babble and appropriate Prune; not shying away from the hard parts].
Agree that this is an issue, but I think it can be addressed—certainly at least well enough that there’d be worthwhile value-of-info in running such a thing.
I’d be happy to contribute a bit of effort, if someone else is taking the lead. I think most of my efforts will be directed elsewhere, but for example I’d be happy to think through what such a program should look like; help write justificatory parts of grant applications; and maybe mentor / similar.