Rosser: I am not going to get into the debate about the specific math of your model as others have already done so.
There’s only one equation in this post and it’s a standard one. Were you referring to the Speed Limit post? I already put all original math in that post into abeyance pending further investigation.
I’m reasonably certain the McCabe I was quoting isn’t your McCabe.
I suppose I have a unique professional perspective on how tragic the class of warped thinking revealed in old-style group selectionism is likely to be. (“You can get all these wonderfully aesthetic results just by optimizing for criterion X—oops the real result is cannibalism.”) Future posts should make this clear.
Rosser: I am not going to get into the debate about the specific math of your model as others have already done so.
There’s only one equation in this post and it’s a standard one. Were you referring to the Speed Limit post? I already put all original math in that post into abeyance pending further investigation.
I’m reasonably certain the McCabe I was quoting isn’t your McCabe.
I suppose I have a unique professional perspective on how tragic the class of warped thinking revealed in old-style group selectionism is likely to be. (“You can get all these wonderfully aesthetic results just by optimizing for criterion X—oops the real result is cannibalism.”) Future posts should make this clear.