One thing I’m missing from this whole horcrux discussion is: What happens if you die of age, and have a horcrux?
People just seem to assume that once you have a horcrux, you won’t wither and die.
But we have no indication to believe this is what actually happens. canon!Voldemort catches a rebounding killing curse, and the horcrux doesn’t make him live on in perfect health. Instead he is very close to death, has no body, and needs to possess animals or other humans to extort some influence.
So what happens if you have a horcrux, and come close to dying from old age? It seems to me that your body would die, and you’d need some avenue to live again, and that is not a nice prospect at all. If you have access to a philospher’s stone you wouldn’t have such a problem, but then you wouldn’t need a horcrux in the first place. What else can you do? Possess another human, who suffers greatly from it. Or the ritual that requires a servant of yours to sacrifice a limb; oh, and there’s only a limited supplies of bones from your father, so you can’t repeat it indefinitely.
In summary, it seems that a single death doesn’t give you 100k+ years of live without additional major costs.
One thing I’m missing from this whole horcrux discussion is: What happens if you die of age, and have a horcrux?
People just seem to assume that once you have a horcrux, you won’t wither and die.
But we have no indication to believe this is what actually happens. canon!Voldemort catches a rebounding killing curse, and the horcrux doesn’t make him live on in perfect health. Instead he is very close to death, has no body, and needs to possess animals or other humans to extort some influence.
So what happens if you have a horcrux, and come close to dying from old age? It seems to me that your body would die, and you’d need some avenue to live again, and that is not a nice prospect at all. If you have access to a philospher’s stone you wouldn’t have such a problem, but then you wouldn’t need a horcrux in the first place. What else can you do? Possess another human, who suffers greatly from it. Or the ritual that requires a servant of yours to sacrifice a limb; oh, and there’s only a limited supplies of bones from your father, so you can’t repeat it indefinitely.
In summary, it seems that a single death doesn’t give you 100k+ years of live without additional major costs.