Suppose there were some gears in physics we weren’t smart enough to understand at all. What would that look like to us?
It would look like phenomena that appears intrinsically random, wouldn’t it? Like imagine there were a simple rule about the spin of electrons that we just. don’t. get. Instead noticing the simple pattern (“Electrons are up if the number of Planck timesteps since the beginning of the universe is a multiple of 3”), we’d only be able to figure out statistical rules of thumb for our measurements (“we measure electrons as up 1⁄3 of the time”).
My intuitions conflict here. One the one hand, I totally expect there to be phenomena in physics we just don’t get. On the other hand, the research programs you might undertake under those conditions (collect phenomena which appear intrinsically random and search for patterns) feel like crackpottery.
If you do set out on this quest, Bell’s inequality and friends will at least put hard restrictions on where you could look for a rule underlying seemingly random wave function collapse. The more restricted your search, the sooner you’ll find a needle!
Suppose there were some gears in physics we weren’t smart enough to understand at all. What would that look like to us?
It would look like phenomena that appears intrinsically random, wouldn’t it? Like imagine there were a simple rule about the spin of electrons that we just. don’t. get. Instead noticing the simple pattern (“Electrons are up if the number of Planck timesteps since the beginning of the universe is a multiple of 3”), we’d only be able to figure out statistical rules of thumb for our measurements (“we measure electrons as up 1⁄3 of the time”).
My intuitions conflict here. One the one hand, I totally expect there to be phenomena in physics we just don’t get. On the other hand, the research programs you might undertake under those conditions (collect phenomena which appear intrinsically random and search for patterns) feel like crackpottery.
Maybe I should put more weight on superdetermism.
If you do set out on this quest, Bell’s inequality and friends will at least put hard restrictions on where you could look for a rule underlying seemingly random wave function collapse. The more restricted your search, the sooner you’ll find a needle!