I think if we try to stop punishing for deception altogether, we are missing on a good solution for the prisoner’s dilemma.
It’s reasonable (though not obvious) that we don’t punish for unconscious deception. And you also make a good point that we shouldn’t punish for self-awareness.
But I think, an important distinction has to be made between self-awareness and self-control. I am aware of many things, but I don’t necessarily have active control over all of them, mostly because it would require a different level of mental energy.
In my books, a controlled and deliberated lie is much worse than an unconscious one or even a lie you are simply aware of.
You could say that a “lie” is as bad, as little mental effort it would require of the “liar” to avoid it.
I think if we try to stop punishing for deception altogether, we are missing on a good solution for the prisoner’s dilemma.
It’s reasonable (though not obvious) that we don’t punish for unconscious deception. And you also make a good point that we shouldn’t punish for self-awareness.
But I think, an important distinction has to be made between self-awareness and self-control. I am aware of many things, but I don’t necessarily have active control over all of them, mostly because it would require a different level of mental energy.
In my books, a controlled and deliberated lie is much worse than an unconscious one or even a lie you are simply aware of.
You could say that a “lie” is as bad, as little mental effort it would require of the “liar” to avoid it.