IQ seems like the sort of thing Feynman could be “honestly” motivatedly wrong about. The thing I’m trying to point at is that Feynman seemingly took pride in being a straight talker, in contrast to how Yudkowsky takes pride in not lying.
These are different things. Straight talkers sometimes say false or exaggerated things out of sloppiness, but they actively want listeners to know their reporting algorithm. Prudently selecting which true sentences to report in the service of a covert goal is not lying, but it’s definitely not straight talk.
IQ seems like the sort of thing Feynman could be “honestly” motivatedly wrong about. The thing I’m trying to point at is that Feynman seemingly took pride in being a straight talker, in contrast to how Yudkowsky takes pride in not lying.
These are different things. Straight talkers sometimes say false or exaggerated things out of sloppiness, but they actively want listeners to know their reporting algorithm. Prudently selecting which true sentences to report in the service of a covert goal is not lying, but it’s definitely not straight talk.