Just to make clear, are you saying that we should treat chickens how humans want to treat them, or how chickens do? Because if the former, then yeah, CEV can easily find out whether we’d want them to have good lives or not (and I think it would see we do).
But chickens don’t (I think) have much of an ethical system, and if we incorporated their values into what CEV calculates, then we’d be left with some important human values, but also a lot of chicken feed.
Thanks, Benito. Do we know that we shouldn’t have a lot of chicken feed? My point in asking this is just that we’re baking in a lot of the answer by choosing which minds we extrapolate in the first place. Now, I have no problem baking in answers—I want to bake in my answers—but I’m just highlighting that it’s not obvious that the set of human minds is the right one to extrapolate.
BTW, I think the “brain reward pathways” between humans and chickens aren’t that different. Maybe you were thinking about the particular, concrete stimuli that are found to be rewarding rather than the general architecture.
Just to make clear, are you saying that we should treat chickens how humans want to treat them, or how chickens do? Because if the former, then yeah, CEV can easily find out whether we’d want them to have good lives or not (and I think it would see we do).
But chickens don’t (I think) have much of an ethical system, and if we incorporated their values into what CEV calculates, then we’d be left with some important human values, but also a lot of chicken feed.
Thanks, Benito. Do we know that we shouldn’t have a lot of chicken feed? My point in asking this is just that we’re baking in a lot of the answer by choosing which minds we extrapolate in the first place. Now, I have no problem baking in answers—I want to bake in my answers—but I’m just highlighting that it’s not obvious that the set of human minds is the right one to extrapolate.
BTW, I think the “brain reward pathways” between humans and chickens aren’t that different. Maybe you were thinking about the particular, concrete stimuli that are found to be rewarding rather than the general architecture.