The critic could respond that our only measure of a moral system is whether its conclusions agree with our intuitions, so we should find conclusions about which we have strong intuitions.
The relativist could respond that our intuitions are noisy and so we should use error-correcting heuristics like Occam’s Razor and bounding the score impact of each intuition.
The critic could respond that our only measure of a moral system is whether its conclusions agree with our intuitions, so we should find conclusions about which we have strong intuitions.
The relativist could respond that our intuitions are noisy and so we should use error-correcting heuristics like Occam’s Razor and bounding the score impact of each intuition.