I haven’t read all of Asimov, but in general, “the” law has a much richer body of interpretation and application than the Laws of Robotics did, and also have authoritative, external dispute resolution processes.
I don’t think so. The Counselor function is just a shorthand for the process of figuring out how the law might fairly apply to X. An agent may or may not have the drive to figure that out by default, but the goal of an LFAI system is to give it that motivation. Whether it figures out the law by asking another agent or simply reasoning about the law itself is ultimately not that important.
I haven’t read all of Asimov, but in general, “the” law has a much richer body of interpretation and application than the Laws of Robotics did, and also have authoritative, external dispute resolution processes.
I don’t think so. The Counselor function is just a shorthand for the process of figuring out how the law might fairly apply to X. An agent may or may not have the drive to figure that out by default, but the goal of an LFAI system is to give it that motivation. Whether it figures out the law by asking another agent or simply reasoning about the law itself is ultimately not that important.