This sounds like an extension of how mindkilling topics like politics are (with a few reasonable exceptions like Zvi’s series on COVID) already restricted to blogposts. It has the advantage of keeping things controlled without shutting down conversation entirely. It has the disadvantage of adding complexity.
I think your proposal is good enough to be worth considering or possibly iterating upon.
This sounds like an extension of how mindkilling topics like politics are (with a few reasonable exceptions like Zvi’s series on COVID) already restricted to blogposts. It has the advantage of keeping things controlled without shutting down conversation entirely. It has the disadvantage of adding complexity.
I think your proposal is good enough to be worth considering or possibly iterating upon.