What would be for you an example of inconsistent behavior, then?
If you say that eating meat is wrong, but then eat it.
If you climb the abstraction tree high enough, you can always get to consistency, if only in the form of “Do what your morals tell you to do”.
That’s true, but “do what your morals tell you to do” is vacuous and not action-guiding. Morality must be action-guiding, and “In [situation], do X” and “In [situation], do what RNG tells you” are both action-guiding.
In particular, “X is wrong” is a different claim from “X is inconsistent” or “X is not logically coherent”.
If I say “Eating meat is wrong, one should never do something wrong, it is sometimes permissible to eat meat”, there is a contradiction, and that requires at least one of the three statements to be false.
Because “do what your morals tell you to do” is self-referential, as your morals are what you should do. “Do what your morals tell you to do” unpacks to “do what you should do”, so if someone asks you what you should do, you can only respond “What I should do”. “Do what the RNG tells you to do” is not self-referential.
If you say that eating meat is wrong, but then eat it.
That’s true, but “do what your morals tell you to do” is vacuous and not action-guiding. Morality must be action-guiding, and “In [situation], do X” and “In [situation], do what RNG tells you” are both action-guiding.
If I say “Eating meat is wrong, one should never do something wrong, it is sometimes permissible to eat meat”, there is a contradiction, and that requires at least one of the three statements to be false.
Lessee… You said
So for this situation the morals would be
if (coinflip == true) { say “Eating meat is wrong” } else { say “Eating meat is not wrong” }
Eat meat
I don’t really see the difference in that respect between “do what your morals tell you to” and “do what the RNG tells you to”.
Because “do what your morals tell you to do” is self-referential, as your morals are what you should do. “Do what your morals tell you to do” unpacks to “do what you should do”, so if someone asks you what you should do, you can only respond “What I should do”. “Do what the RNG tells you to do” is not self-referential.