Discussion threads would truncate for new users from new user comments (experienced user comments on new user comments would be invisible to new users). Our caching gets more complicated. Many candidate tests for “experienced” seem obvious, but some might be very easy to game (funny comments on HPMOR posts qualify you).
This seems absurdly hard to implement
It seems not hard to implement naively.
Discussion threads would truncate for new users from new user comments (experienced user comments on new user comments would be invisible to new users).
Our caching gets more complicated.
Many candidate tests for “experienced” seem obvious, but some might be very easy to game (funny comments on HPMOR posts qualify you).