FWIW, I find it hard to make judgements on these kinds of aggregate statistics, and would be kind of surprised if other people know how to make judgements on these either. “Having worked at a scaling lab” or “being involved with a AI Safety grantmaking organization” or “being interested in AI control” just aren’t that informative pieces of information, especially I don’t even have individual profiles.
My sense is that if you want people to be able to actually come to trust your criteria, you will either have to be more specific, or just list people’s names (the latter of which would be ideal, and also would create concrete points of accountability).
FWIW, I find it hard to make judgements on these kinds of aggregate statistics, and would be kind of surprised if other people know how to make judgements on these either. “Having worked at a scaling lab” or “being involved with a AI Safety grantmaking organization” or “being interested in AI control” just aren’t that informative pieces of information, especially I don’t even have individual profiles.
My sense is that if you want people to be able to actually come to trust your criteria, you will either have to be more specific, or just list people’s names (the latter of which would be ideal, and also would create concrete points of accountability).