August 2015 Media Thread
This is the monthly thread for posting media of various types that you’ve found that you enjoy. Post what you’re reading, listening to, watching, and your opinion of it. Post recommendations to blogs. Post whatever media you feel like discussing! To see previous recommendations, check out the older threads.
Rules:
Please avoid downvoting recommendations just because you don’t personally like the recommended material; remember that liking is a two-place word. If you can point out a specific flaw in a person’s recommendation, consider posting a comment to that effect.
If you want to post something that (you know) has been recommended before, but have another recommendation to add, please link to the original, so that the reader has both recommendations.
Please post only under one of the already created subthreads, and never directly under the parent media thread.
Use the “Other Media” thread if you believe the piece of media you want to discuss doesn’t fit under any of the established categories.
Use the “Meta” thread if you want to discuss about the monthly media thread itself (e.g. to propose adding/removing/splitting/merging subthreads, or to discuss the type of content properly belonging to each subthread) or for any other question or issue you may have about the thread or the rules.
Short Online Texts Thread
Politics/religion:
“The Really Big One: An earthquake will destroy a sizable portion of the coastal Northwest. The question is when.”
“Of Malevolent Democracies and Benevolent Autocracies: A Very Short Quantitative History of Political Regimes, Part 1.9325”
“Utopian for Beginners: An amateur linguist loses control of the language he invented” (where are those Ukrainians now, I wonder?)
Statistics/AI/meta-science:
Ch6: “Deep Learning” (latest in Nielsen’s Neural Networks and Deep Learning)
“How One Man Poisoned a City’s Water Supply (and Saved Millions of Children’s Lives in the Process)”(on John L. Leal & water chlorination)
“Reanalyses of Randomized Clinical Trial Data”, Ebrahim et al 2014
“The Aging of Science”
“List of 19 Natural Experiments” (commentary)
“The Null Ritual: What You Always Wanted to Know About Significance Testing but Were Afraid to Ask”, Gigerenzer et al 2004
Psychology/biology:
“Physics of Wound Healing I: Energy Considerations”, Apell 2012
“The Biodeterminist’s Guide to Parenting”
“A Year of Spaced Repetition Software in the Classroom”
“Whole-personality emulation”, Bainbridge 2012
“Does it pay to know your MBTI type?”
“Burn-in, bias, and the rationality of anchoring”, Lieder et al 2012
Technology:
“The Market for Silver Bullets”, Grigg 2008
“Invisibility theory”
Economics:
“Economic Gains Resulting from the Reduction in Children’s Exposure to Lead in the United States”, Grosse et al 2002
“When the Doctor Is Not Needed”
“How The Talmud Became A Best Seller in South Korea” (no one tell them about signaling or genetics)
“The Patent Troll You Don’t Read About In Bar-Code Inventor’s Obituaries”
Philosophy:
“The Copenhagen Interpretation of Ethics”
Fiction:
“Quantitative patterns of stylistic influence in the evolution of literature”, Hughes et al 2012
“I Name Thee Annihilator!”
Re: those Ukrainians A trusted acquaintance of mine has worked for this same Bakhtiyarov and never had a single kind word to say about either his ethics or his brains. Do not summon him from wherever he is.
Would you mind sharing a list of all blog feeds you are subscribed to? Perhaps as OPML file?
http://www.gwern.net/docs/personal/rss-subscriptions.opml
I found this awesome, brilliant analysis of the works of Neal Stephenson from a political and sociological angle.
Ok, it was me, I wrote this.
Would you prefer I leave comments on the page itself?
Thanks for your comments, I appreciate your points. I’ve replied in the comments of the linked article.
The website seems to be down.
Thanks for the heads up. Should be working now.
This made me laugh: http://www.clickhole.com/article/5-absolutely-stunning-examples-mathematics-nature-2081
the way you think about habits is wrong
extinction bursts
Extinction burst
Supp 1
Supp 2
Fiction Books Thread
I have to recommend Phyl-Undhu from Nick Land (yes the guy from XenoSystems), yes is a little short, but if you like (or think you would like) Lovecraft then you should read it. I thought it was wonderfully written, and it get the cosmic horror/lovecraftian atmosphere very well.
Still Alice (our obituaries)
The Martian (Weir)
Asimov’s Puzzles of the Black Widowers (review)
‘Mental traveler’, a poem by William Blake.
I just found out that some comic books I read in Finnish in the 80s were originally published in English in 1976 in a magazine called Starstream. I re-read the comics, which are an anthology of comic adaptations of various golden age SF short stories. They also mostly stick to the source material, such as John Campbell’s Who Goes There, which was also the basis for John Carpenter’s The Thing. Generally it’s quite a bit better than what you’d expect from “newsstand comic book from 1976”, and a lot of the stories are quite weird, from the mix of outdated science and narrative conventions, source material from authors who sometimes were actually very good and the general mismatch with what you’d expect from the dated comic book format. Robert Silverberg, Isaac Asimov, Robert Bloch, Poul Anderson and Theodore Sturgeon are some of the more notable authors who get an adaption.
Read The Martian—not bad I guess, but a sort of celebration of terrible ethics.
The ethical dimension is lampshaded at a few points and it’s pointed out that it’s not quite that clearcut as ‘we are wasting billions of dollars to riskily save one volunteer’; I felt he implies that the death might also kill or set back the space program, which makes the choice a bit different. I’m not sure he’s entirely wrong: the public has really weird beliefs and attitudes (as this absurd ‘Cecil the Lion’ dustup has reminded us yet again) and it’s entirely possible things might play out as depicted in Weir’s novel. The last shuttle deaths did kill that program, after all.
TV and Movies (Animation) Thread
Watched a lot of robot anime last month.
Rewatched RahXephon. I’d tie it with NGE at 9⁄10. I especially liked the first two episodes. I thought the romance in it was quite good, too. The animation goes off-model from time to time, but it’s serviceable. The music is wonderful, especially the closing theme https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aTUy44JA8w
I also watched Eureka Seven and found it vastly inferior to RahXephon—maybe 5⁄10 and that’s pushing it.
I’ve been enjoying Knights of Sidonia [slight spoilers] - a half-and-half mix of neat science fiction and annoying fan service. There was an interesting romance in the first season (and one wonderful scene of a couple stranded in space) but it’s pretty ridiculous how every female (including the eldritch monstrosity) loves the oblivious protagonist. Also, Izana has the potential to be super interesting but zer potential is mostly wasted.
As for the animation, I know it is controversial, but I think it’s quite good. It’s also obviously the future of the medium—people will get used to it. I’ll give it 7⁄10.
I still enjoyed the setting and some of the fights but I thought the second season was a fair bit worse than the first due to (as you mention) too much focus on harem antics, combined with a reduction in the overall sense of urgency/plot momentum.
What I find interesting about RahXephon is that having watched it and NGE several times and read staff interviews for both etc is that in almost every respect, RX is clearly better thought out and more competently executed*, and yet, it’s NGE which ultimately somehow turns out to be greater than the sum of its parts of RX and a part of anime history, while RX is ‘merely’ one of the best mechas around, especially from that era.
* with the exception of the music—RX’s is quite good but Sagisu’s NGE work is still considered one of the best, up there with Kanno’s Cowboy Bebop.
I agree, there is some magic to NGE that RahXephon doesn’t have—but I’m not sure how much of that is caused by the fact that I saw NGE first and it was the first Anime I ever watched. I love Neuromancer, but much of my love for it comes from the fact that it was the first science fiction novel I ever read. I had no antibodies. If I had read Vinge first, it’s likely I wouldn’t have been too impressed with Neuromancer, which has as many flaws as NGE.
I can’t justify giving NGE a higher score for the reasons you described, but I do slightly prefer it—though less so after re-watching RahXephon.
Expelled from Paradise (review)
I watched it based on this recommendation. I’ll second it—great fun, great animation, but I don’t mind CGI. I thought I detected some Hannu Rajaniemi influences, too.
Gubhtu V guvax vg fubhyq unir raqrq jvgu gur gjb wbvavat gur iblntr. Qvatb’f bowrpgvbaf gb fvzhyngvba jrer cheryl n znggre bs gur cbyvgvpf naq Natryn pyrneyl cersreerq yvsr nf na rz. Gur erny jbeyq ybbxrq cerggl pehzzl.
Just from reading the wiki page: it has a critique of a transhumanist society?
Yes; it’s strongly implied that being an upload is great, but however Deva has been captured by a tyranny which deliberately keeps resources restricted in order to force ems to scramble for survival and compliance with the central government in order to stay alive, and which reacts to events by doubling down on control & liquidation of dissenters and outside elements. (So you could easily read this as a critique of North Korea, with Deva=Pyongyang.) Which is entirely true and I expect that an upload society could very easily tilt into an even more extreme totalitarian tyranny between the evolutionary pressures and direct modification of minds.
That sounds like a very badly done transhuman society.
What’s the point of comparison? Our best political theorists have not managed to make good societies. Look at real wages over the last few decades.
Whose real wages?
I haven’t looked, but I suspect that global real wages went up.
Before we even make this comparison, I find it extremely hard to believe that the fall in real wages over the past few decades was created by following the advice of our best political theorists. Neoliberalism has not been known for listening to theorists.
If it wasn’t imperfect, there wouldn’t be much of a story. I think it’s a well done transhuman society simply because it’s bad in a way that is not just possible but a pretty plausible extrapolation: someone is usually root.
Ah. So you’re only really interested in bad things.
peckishowl.deviantart.com/gallery/41509876/OAKENTOONS
a collection of collages from the Hobbit trilogy. Kind of like comics.
Things that we haven’t dropped yet from the current season—there’s a bumper crop:
Classroom Crisis—does for corporate politics what Shirobako did for anime production. I have had those conversations with management...
Game of Laplace—trappings of a detective/mystery series, but more psychological thriller than particularly rational so far; still, has potential and the thriller is well done.
GATE—still not sure, but still watching. Fantasyland attempts to invade Japan, Japan retaliates, SDF starts a softly-softly invasion of fantasyland (after basically a massacre of their entire combined armed forces, medieval knights vs modern weapons isn’t really a contest). It raises interesting issues, and could get very good if it actually follows them up—though it has not so far, and will be quite banal if it never does; will report back here either way.
Honourable mention: Shimoneta. I was expecting a series with this premise to fail the ten second fanservice test, but we ended up watching the entire first episode and it is surprisingly worth seeing an episode (no idea if it remains worthwhile, we have not been brave enough to try a second!). Laugh-out-loud funny, unexpectedly high production quality. Think Fahrenheit 451 crossed with Gurren Lagann crossed with a whole lot of WRONG and WTF and NSFW.
EDIT: have read ahead in the GATE manga. It doesn’t quite ascend to the epic “The Irregular at Magic High School” Kim-Jong-Il-propaganda levels of Gary Stu, but that’s sadly the direction it’s firmly headed in and unless they’ve rewritten the script for the anime it looks like it’s going to avoid any redeeming features it’s raised the possibility of. Pity. Dropping.
Gakkou Gurashi is by far my favorite show of the current season. For anyone who doesn’t mind moe and wants to see a more exciting twist on the genre, I’d recommend watching the (entire) first episode with as little information/spoilers as possible.
I’m also enjoying GATE and hope that it plays to its original elements rather than being too haremy. I tried reading the manga but the only translation available in a readable resolution is very rough.
Gakkou Gurashi failed the “you have five minutes to make me care about any of this” test initially for us; a friend later convinced us to watch the first episode all the way to the end—they were absolutely correct and it is now firmly back on our to-watch-more-of list, but haven’t got round to confirming it stays good yet, good to have corroboration.
Another honourable mention: Akagami no Shirayukihime; strong, actually intelligent female protagonist in a misogynistic fantasy setting. Straight romance. It’s a little self-aware initially—she tears up in surprise a bit too often when men aren’t actively horrible to her—but gets better. Not as strong as Akatsuki no Yona though, would really like to see a second season of that.
I picked it up on recommendation from /r/rational. Then I fell over laughing, having accidentally downloaded ep 4 instead of ep 1. Then I watched ep 1 and was so excited to get to the “flip”.
As much as I enjoy the show I’m not sure what makes it rationality material...
Well, it was mentioned in the Friday Open Thread where things don’t have to be rationality material.
Music Thread
Tandu Psychedelic trance—very energetic and playful.
The act of killing by Joshua Oppenheimer. I just saw him in an ABC inteview, incredibly well-spoken.
Also, James Altucher on London Real.
Great documentary, wrong subthread
I started listening to Dragonforce this past month. Their lyrics are fall-over-laughing funny.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Metal/comments/13t8dr/what_are_some_complaints_about_great_metal_bands/c773l45
Artists I’ve been listening to recently:
Flaming Lips—“Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots Pt. 1”
Blue Sky Black Death—“And Stars, Ringed”
Red Hot Chili Peppers—“Torture Me”
Tool—“Wings for Marie Pt. 2 (10,000 Days)”
Bjork—“Innocence”
Touhou:
the latest TLMC has been released: “Touhou lossless music collection: TLMC v.18 (2015.06.30)” (lossy)
“Fires of Hokkai” (くみちょ; Knights of Round 3 {C77}) [post-rock]
“マンドラゴラの庭” (siva; Gensokyo St. Patrick’s Day {K10}) [Celtic]
“Rince Oiche” (Escarmew; Gensokyo St. Patrick’s Day {K10}) [Celtic]
“Sleepy Maiden” (Marasy; 幻想遊戲<眠>2 {C86}) [classical]
“Septette for a Sleepy Princess” (Marasy; 幻想遊戲<眠>2 {C86}) [classical]
“籠居漏水” (PIROPARU; Kyouon no Ooi Ryouriten {Reitaisai SP}) [instrumental]
“Lotus World” (PIROPARU; Kyouon no Ooi Ryouriten {Reitaisai SP}) [instrumental]
“Going back to Sleeping Night” (Marasy; 幻想遊戲<眠>2 {C86}) [classical]
“Drowsy Eyes” (Marasy; 幻想遊戲<眠>2 {C86}) [classical]
Online Videos Thread
The Power of Having Nothing to Lose. I’d like to add that I don’t enjoy these kinds of videos when I’m in a good mood and free from dysfunctional anxiety. But when they are a factor, it’s really… soothing. I identify with the narrator’s complex of narcissism, wishful thinking, avoidance coping, fear of failure, perfectionism and learned helplessness. I’m impressed that he’s a preeminent executive coach now and I’m a socially anxious LW geek. Throughout my life I’ve had a fear of criticism that has kept me, like many others, from getting shit done. Now I fear all the criticism I haven’t got received and all the mistakes I haven’t made. Oh god I hope I’m not turning into one of those people on psychology forums or support groups that just self-victimise and moan, groan and complain all day like hypochondriacs.
Breathe into your balls. This is my favourite video. It’s explicitly antirational and paradoxically rational.
Fanfiction Thread
Nonfiction Books Thread
New cryonics book coming out later this month:
http://www.amazon.com/Frozen-Life-Personal-Mortality-Experiment/dp/0993334407
Frozen to Life: A Personal Mortality Experiment
by D.J. MacLennan (Author)
Paperback – August 31, 2015
This book might serve as an updated introduction to the cryonics idea. Cryonics organizations badly need some new expository literature any way. They can’t depend on books written a generation or two back because these writings don’t incorporate the experience base of the real, existing practice of cryonics over the past 50 years. This literature doesn’t explain the bearing of current neuroscience, cryobiology and biotechnology on what cryonicists want to do. And it doesn’t address the criticisms directed towards the project, even ones I consider a bit foolish, like “But in the future you won’t know anyone!”
TV and Movies (Live Action) Thread
Podcasts Thread
Hello Internet is a fun “two guys talking” podcast made by two popular youtubers including CGPGray, the guy who made this great video about the future of automation and employment. Low (almost no) informational content, but really enjoyable, and CGPGray will often say things that make it sound as if he’s read at least some of LessWrong/Overcoming Bias. At the very least he’s a transhumanist.
I’ve been looking for a good Anime/Manga podcast? The one’s I’ve found have been ok but not exactly what I’m hoping for. Anyone know of one?
Trash Taste covers lots of topics but the hosts come from an anituber background so they talk about anime a lot.
Other Media Thread
Tools
Clearerthinking.org
Meta Thread
TIME TO GET RELIGION: ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE WILL TORTURE AND ENSLAVE HUMANS TO LEARN FROM…” https://medium.com/@MexConex/endgame-for-human-race-ai-will-enslave-humans-to-learn-from-and-dominate-us-215ed602a66b?source=tw-e89f12bbff65-1438538020152 …
Why did you recommend this?
Prophetic
because it is visionary?
BUY HIGH QUALITY DATA-BASE REGISTERED MACHINE READ-ABLE SCAN-ABLE DRIVER’S LICENSE,ID’S,PASSPORTS AND CITIZENSHIP DOCUMENTS.REAL/FAKE PASSPORTS, DRIVER’S LICENSE,ID CARDS.GENUINE PASSPORTS,DRIVER’S LICENSE AND OTHER DOCUMENTS OF ALL COUNTRIES FOR SALE.FAKE PASSPORTS UK FOR SALE, (((docspaul90@gmail.com)))