I read The Martian based off the recommendation here, and found it… okay. (Reporting negative results is important too, right?) It was distinctly less affecting than Gravity (movie), Rocket Girls (or its sequel, or the same author’s Usurper of the Sun), or Moondust: In Search of the Men who Fell to Earth (nonfiction), all of which I recommend to fans of the subject matter.
I also read it based on your recommendation (I think—don’t remember clearly) and I really really liked it. The near-future science is overwhelmingly convincing in a good way. What’s funny is that I thought the characters were pretty shallow and the constantly peppy attitude of the hero not believable and somewhat grating; usually the quality of characters and their development is a must for me, their shallowness ruins any book. Somehow it didn’t happen here. There was just so much of this juicy mind-opening fascinating engaging sciency stuff that kept me at the edge of the chair. I’m really glad I read this book—thanks!
Like Anatoly, I also really liked the book. It’s not very deep in my mind, but it’s just good ol’ fashioned fun, for the kind of people who love hearing of highly technical matters (about which they honestly know little, at least in my case).
Fiction Books Thread
I read The Martian based off the recommendation here, and found it… okay. (Reporting negative results is important too, right?) It was distinctly less affecting than Gravity (movie), Rocket Girls (or its sequel, or the same author’s Usurper of the Sun), or Moondust: In Search of the Men who Fell to Earth (nonfiction), all of which I recommend to fans of the subject matter.
I recommended it, and I am glad for your report! FWIW, I liked it more than Gravity, in part because it was less emotionally affecting.
I also read it based on your recommendation (I think—don’t remember clearly) and I really really liked it. The near-future science is overwhelmingly convincing in a good way. What’s funny is that I thought the characters were pretty shallow and the constantly peppy attitude of the hero not believable and somewhat grating; usually the quality of characters and their development is a must for me, their shallowness ruins any book. Somehow it didn’t happen here. There was just so much of this juicy mind-opening fascinating engaging sciency stuff that kept me at the edge of the chair. I’m really glad I read this book—thanks!
Like Anatoly, I also really liked the book. It’s not very deep in my mind, but it’s just good ol’ fashioned fun, for the kind of people who love hearing of highly technical matters (about which they honestly know little, at least in my case).
Fiction:
Absolute Sandman, vol III, IV
Radiance (review)
Brosh 2013′s Hyperbole and a Half (review)