His understanding of philosophy is barely up to undergraduate level. Sorry, but that’s the way it is.
I feel like the phrasing “barely up to undergraduate level” is like saying something is “basic” or “textbook” not when it’s actually basic or textbook but because it insinuates there is an ocean of knowledge that your opponent has yet to cross. If luke is “barely undergraduate” then I know a lot of philosophy undergrads who might as well not call themselves that.
While I agree that reform is far more likely to be done by a Dewey or Erasmus, your reasoning gives me a very “you must be accepted into our system if you want to criticize it” vibe.
While it’s not actually impossible to reform the teaching on a subject without yourself reaching the highest level in knowledge of it you wish to teach, it is bloody hard.
I know a lot of philosophy undergrads who might as well not call themselves that.
Who arent trying to reform the subject.
“you must be accepted into our system if you want to criticize it
It’s not that. There is just no practical possibility of philosophy, or any other subject, being reformed by someone who does not have a very good grasp of it. You need a good grasp of it just to dagnose the problems.
I feel like the phrasing “barely up to undergraduate level” is like saying something is “basic” or “textbook” not when it’s actually basic or textbook but because it insinuates there is an ocean of knowledge that your opponent has yet to cross. If luke is “barely undergraduate” then I know a lot of philosophy undergrads who might as well not call themselves that.
While I agree that reform is far more likely to be done by a Dewey or Erasmus, your reasoning gives me a very “you must be accepted into our system if you want to criticize it” vibe.
While it’s not actually impossible to reform the teaching on a subject without yourself reaching the highest level in knowledge of it you wish to teach, it is bloody hard.
Who arent trying to reform the subject.
It’s not that. There is just no practical possibility of philosophy, or any other subject, being reformed by someone who does not have a very good grasp of it. You need a good grasp of it just to dagnose the problems.