I think it’s fairly clear that a farm chicken’s life is well below that threshold. If I had the choice between losing consciousness for an hour or spending an hour as a chicken on a factory farm, I would definitely choose the former.
Ninja Edit: I think a lot of people have poor intuitions when comparing life to non-life because our brains are wired to strongly shy away from non-life. That’s why the example I gave above used temporary loss of consciousness rather than death. Even if you don’t buy the above example, I think it’s possible to see that factory-farmed life is worse than death. This article discussed how doctors—the people most familiar with medical treatment—frequently choose to die sooner rather than attempt to prolong their lives when they know they will suffer greatly in their last days. It seems that life on a factory farm would entail much more suffering than death by a common illness.
I don’t see why a chicken would choose any differently. We have no reason to believe that chicken-suffering is categorically different from human-suffering.
If we were to put a bunch of chickens into a room, and on one side of the room was a wolf, and the other side had factory farming cages that protected the chickens from the wolf, I would expect the chickens to run into the cages.
It’s true that chickens can comprehend a wolf much better than they can comprehend factory farming, but I’m not quite sure how that affects this thought experiment.
I think it’s fairly clear that a farm chicken’s life is well below that threshold. If I had the choice between losing consciousness for an hour or spending an hour as a chicken on a factory farm, I would definitely choose the former.
Ninja Edit: I think a lot of people have poor intuitions when comparing life to non-life because our brains are wired to strongly shy away from non-life. That’s why the example I gave above used temporary loss of consciousness rather than death. Even if you don’t buy the above example, I think it’s possible to see that factory-farmed life is worse than death. This article discussed how doctors—the people most familiar with medical treatment—frequently choose to die sooner rather than attempt to prolong their lives when they know they will suffer greatly in their last days. It seems that life on a factory farm would entail much more suffering than death by a common illness.
I probably would too, but I am not a chicken. I think you are over-anthropomorphizing them.
I don’t see why a chicken would choose any differently. We have no reason to believe that chicken-suffering is categorically different from human-suffering.
If we were to put a bunch of chickens into a room, and on one side of the room was a wolf, and the other side had factory farming cages that protected the chickens from the wolf, I would expect the chickens to run into the cages.
It’s true that chickens can comprehend a wolf much better than they can comprehend factory farming, but I’m not quite sure how that affects this thought experiment.
And I expect that a human would do the same thing.
I made a hash of that comment; I’m sorry.
This is testable; give the chickens a lever to peck that knocks them out for an hour.