That’s a very thoughtful response from TurnTrout. I wonder if @Gwern agrees with its main points. If not, it would be good know where he thinks it fails.
I did not understand his response at all, and it sounds like I would have to reread a bunch of Turntrout posts before any further comment would just be talking past each other, so I don’t have anything useful to say. Maybe someone else can re-explain his point better and why I am apparently wrong.
That’s a very thoughtful response from TurnTrout. I wonder if @Gwern agrees with its main points. If not, it would be good know where he thinks it fails.
I did not understand his response at all, and it sounds like I would have to reread a bunch of Turntrout posts before any further comment would just be talking past each other, so I don’t have anything useful to say. Maybe someone else can re-explain his point better and why I am apparently wrong.