You’re familiar with the idea of anthropomorphization, right? Well, by analogy to that, I would call what you did here “rationalistomorphization,” a word I wish was added to LessWrong jargon.
This reaction needs only scope insensitivity to explain, you don’t need to invoke purity. Though I actually agree with you that liberals have a disgust moral center.
If you are told a billion dollars hasn’t been taxed from people in a city, how many people getting to keep a thousand dollars (say) do you imagine? Probably not a million of them. How many hours not worked, or small things that they buy do you imagine? Probably not any.
But now that I think about it, I’d rather have an extra thousand dollars than be able to drink at a particular drinking fountain.
But I don’t think fairness the morality center is necessarily fairness over differing amounts of harm. It could be differing over social status. You could have an inflated sense of fairness, so that you cared much more than the underlying difference in what people get.
But since the harm is trivial, no one is being treated unfairly absent disgust considerations.
You’re familiar with the idea of anthropomorphization, right? Well, by analogy to that, I would call what you did here “rationalistomorphization,” a word I wish was added to LessWrong jargon.
This reaction needs only scope insensitivity to explain, you don’t need to invoke purity. Though I actually agree with you that liberals have a disgust moral center.
How so?
If you are told a billion dollars hasn’t been taxed from people in a city, how many people getting to keep a thousand dollars (say) do you imagine? Probably not a million of them. How many hours not worked, or small things that they buy do you imagine? Probably not any.
But now that I think about it, I’d rather have an extra thousand dollars than be able to drink at a particular drinking fountain.
But I don’t think fairness the morality center is necessarily fairness over differing amounts of harm. It could be differing over social status. You could have an inflated sense of fairness, so that you cared much more than the underlying difference in what people get.