So in all that long period of open war, during which Lily & James Potter and Alice & Frank Longbottom both fought Voldemort and survived three times each, the strongest Light wizard in Britain never crossed wands with his foe?
Sure. We are told Voldemort feared Dumbledore, are we not? Does a chess player immediately send out his queen to duel the other player’s queen? And is this not exactly what happened with the previous Dark Lord—were we not explicitly told in canon that Dumbledore only encountered Grindelwald at their final clash and they never met between that and the death of his sister?
We are told Voldemort feared Dumbledore, are we not?
Well, were we, though? What chapter was that in? Or are we discussing canon now? I admit I’m somewhat confused.
were we not explicitly told in canon that Dumbledore only encountered Grindelwald at their final clash and they never met between that and the death of his sister?
Yes, but that was due to Dumbledore’s rather cowardly dithering. The situation with Voldemort is rather different.
If your idea is correct, I would expect there were a few well-publicized instances of Dumbledore interrupting a Death Eater raid in a flash of phoenix fire, sending Voldemort running with his tail between his legs. That… doesn’t really sound like MoRdemort, does it?
I’m pretty sure MoRdemort (pre-Quirrell-meld) is meant to be very much like canon!Voldemort—nasty, ruthless, very magically powerful, in possession of exactly one good idea (the dark mark), and as intelligent as Rowling could write him (not an insult to Rowling). When asked to outwit a dark lord (in chapter 39, I believe?) Harry thinks that Voldemort wouldn’t be much of a challenge, but Quirrell would be another matter entirely.
As Dumbledore says, Voldemort was never Dumbledore’s destined foe. But he wasn’t Harry’s destined foe either. He had to be shattered by Dumbledore so he could transmute into Quirrellmort, who is Harry’s destined foe. So Voldemort is an intermediate step, and obviously not as smart/dangerous as his final incarnation as Quirrellmort.
Harry thinks that Voldemort wouldn’t be much of a challenge, but Quirrell would be another matter entirely.
Doubtless Harry based that belief on his extensive experience with Voldemort. Dumbledore’s opinion, on the other hand:
“Aye, it is he,” Albus said. “Azkaban has endured impenetrable for ages, only to fall to an ordinary Animagus potion. It is too clever and too impossible, which was ever Voldemort’s signature since the days he was known as Tom Riddle. Anyone who wished to forge that signature must needs be as cunning as Voldemort himself to do so. And there is no one else in the world who would accidentally overestimate my wit, and leave me a message I cannot understand at all.”
So in all that long period of open war, during which Lily & James Potter and Alice & Frank Longbottom both fought Voldemort and survived three times each, the strongest Light wizard in Britain never crossed wands with his foe?
Sure. We are told Voldemort feared Dumbledore, are we not? Does a chess player immediately send out his queen to duel the other player’s queen? And is this not exactly what happened with the previous Dark Lord—were we not explicitly told in canon that Dumbledore only encountered Grindelwald at their final clash and they never met between that and the death of his sister?
Well, were we, though? What chapter was that in? Or are we discussing canon now? I admit I’m somewhat confused.
Yes, but that was due to Dumbledore’s rather cowardly dithering. The situation with Voldemort is rather different.
If your idea is correct, I would expect there were a few well-publicized instances of Dumbledore interrupting a Death Eater raid in a flash of phoenix fire, sending Voldemort running with his tail between his legs. That… doesn’t really sound like MoRdemort, does it?
Canon. MoR introduces extra difficulties like the implied Nazi blood-sacrifice empowering of Grindelwald.
I don’t know what to make of MoRdemort. If I did, I think a fair number of obscurities or mysteries would snap into place.
I’m pretty sure MoRdemort (pre-Quirrell-meld) is meant to be very much like canon!Voldemort—nasty, ruthless, very magically powerful, in possession of exactly one good idea (the dark mark), and as intelligent as Rowling could write him (not an insult to Rowling). When asked to outwit a dark lord (in chapter 39, I believe?) Harry thinks that Voldemort wouldn’t be much of a challenge, but Quirrell would be another matter entirely.
As Dumbledore says, Voldemort was never Dumbledore’s destined foe. But he wasn’t Harry’s destined foe either. He had to be shattered by Dumbledore so he could transmute into Quirrellmort, who is Harry’s destined foe. So Voldemort is an intermediate step, and obviously not as smart/dangerous as his final incarnation as Quirrellmort.
Doubtless Harry based that belief on his extensive experience with Voldemort. Dumbledore’s opinion, on the other hand: