I don’t think cows and chickens have much real sense of long term contentment. Pointlessness was perhaps a bad choice of word, since it implies human-style abstract thinking. I didn’t mean the chicken sits in its cage thinking “man, what is the meaning of life? Why do I sit hear every day? Nothing changes… nothing gets accomplished, what am I doing with my lif—” (abruptly gets its head cut off).
But I do think there may be a sort of proto-wondering. There’s no complex question or desire for change, it just sits there with a vague dissatisfaction about its existence. I don’t think there’s a way to prove this yet, and probably never. (Unless we identify the exact neuron pattern for it in humans and discover something very similar in chickens. Maybe.)
Food and sleep are definitely sources of pleasure, but being able to get exercise is another important one. Resting is nice, but if you’re stuck in the same place too long you get cranky and irritable, and if you’re stuck in the same place for weeks.
I believe chicken-farming is less ethical than cow farming because chickens are literally stuck in either a 1′x1′ box for their entire life, or they are thrown in a giant coop where each chicken still only gets about a cubic foot of space. In addition, they are given growth hormones to maximize production of meat, making them grow larger than their legs can support, leaving them practically immobile if not actually breaking their legs. Describing this situation as “they get to sit around and eat all day” is pretty significantly mischaracterizing it.
On the flipside, cows by nature need to be able to graze, so they usually get to move around. I consider that a step up, but if they injure themselves while walking they’re pretty much screwed. I’m a little less angry about this because, honestly that IS the situation they’d face in the wild (by contrast, the chicken situation is absolutely nothing like how they’d exist in the natural world). But they still are pumped full of food and chemicals that are not healthy for them.
Just one comment on chicken farming. I’m not too sure if you have actually worked or spent a large amount of time in a chicken processing plant or chicken farm, but you have used incorrect specifics about it. I have worked in one and the facts you used about chickens being “literally stuck in a 1′x1′ box… or in a giant coop where each chicken still only gets about a cubic foot of space” is actually wrong—at least on the farms I have witnessed firsthand. If meat is stressed throughout life, and in particular before death, then it will be a terrible product. Businesses do not want bad products. Chicken farming actually regulates the heat for perfect comfort, delivers a constant amount of fresh water, a mixture of dietary requirements that delivers the right growth (if growth is too fast then it becomes a bad product), and also perfect amounts of light. Also chickens have been domesticated so what is the situation they would face in the wild? Instead of being eaten by humans they would be eaten by foxes, wolves, dogs, etc. I think that would be more traumatic (if they actually knew what that was) than being rendered unconscious through an electric shock before a quick death.
I realize the grandparent explicitly mentioned chicken meat, but I think a lot of the memes about chicken mistreatment come out of the egg industry, and may have crosspollinated. Do you have comparable insights about egg-laying chickens’ conditions?
I don’t think cows and chickens have much real sense of long term contentment. Pointlessness was perhaps a bad choice of word, since it implies human-style abstract thinking. I didn’t mean the chicken sits in its cage thinking “man, what is the meaning of life? Why do I sit hear every day? Nothing changes… nothing gets accomplished, what am I doing with my lif—” (abruptly gets its head cut off).
But I do think there may be a sort of proto-wondering. There’s no complex question or desire for change, it just sits there with a vague dissatisfaction about its existence. I don’t think there’s a way to prove this yet, and probably never. (Unless we identify the exact neuron pattern for it in humans and discover something very similar in chickens. Maybe.)
Food and sleep are definitely sources of pleasure, but being able to get exercise is another important one. Resting is nice, but if you’re stuck in the same place too long you get cranky and irritable, and if you’re stuck in the same place for weeks.
I believe chicken-farming is less ethical than cow farming because chickens are literally stuck in either a 1′x1′ box for their entire life, or they are thrown in a giant coop where each chicken still only gets about a cubic foot of space. In addition, they are given growth hormones to maximize production of meat, making them grow larger than their legs can support, leaving them practically immobile if not actually breaking their legs. Describing this situation as “they get to sit around and eat all day” is pretty significantly mischaracterizing it.
On the flipside, cows by nature need to be able to graze, so they usually get to move around. I consider that a step up, but if they injure themselves while walking they’re pretty much screwed. I’m a little less angry about this because, honestly that IS the situation they’d face in the wild (by contrast, the chicken situation is absolutely nothing like how they’d exist in the natural world). But they still are pumped full of food and chemicals that are not healthy for them.
Just one comment on chicken farming. I’m not too sure if you have actually worked or spent a large amount of time in a chicken processing plant or chicken farm, but you have used incorrect specifics about it. I have worked in one and the facts you used about chickens being “literally stuck in a 1′x1′ box… or in a giant coop where each chicken still only gets about a cubic foot of space” is actually wrong—at least on the farms I have witnessed firsthand. If meat is stressed throughout life, and in particular before death, then it will be a terrible product. Businesses do not want bad products. Chicken farming actually regulates the heat for perfect comfort, delivers a constant amount of fresh water, a mixture of dietary requirements that delivers the right growth (if growth is too fast then it becomes a bad product), and also perfect amounts of light. Also chickens have been domesticated so what is the situation they would face in the wild? Instead of being eaten by humans they would be eaten by foxes, wolves, dogs, etc. I think that would be more traumatic (if they actually knew what that was) than being rendered unconscious through an electric shock before a quick death.
I realize the grandparent explicitly mentioned chicken meat, but I think a lot of the memes about chicken mistreatment come out of the egg industry, and may have crosspollinated. Do you have comparable insights about egg-laying chickens’ conditions?