As far as I can tell, “the standard Dutch book arguments” aren’t even a reason why one’s preferences must conform to all the VNM axioms, much less a “pretty good” reason.
(We’ve had this discussion many times before, and it frustrates me that people seem to forget about this every time.)
I too get frustrated that people seem to forget about the arguments against your positions every time and keep bringing up positions long addressed :P
We can dig into it again, might be worth carving out some explicit time for it if you want to. Otherwise it seems fine for you to register your disagreement. My guess is it could be good to link to some of the past conversations if you have a link handy for the benefit of other readers (I don’t right now).
As far as I can tell, “the standard Dutch book arguments” aren’t even a reason why one’s preferences must conform to all the VNM axioms, much less a “pretty good” reason.
(We’ve had this discussion many times before, and it frustrates me that people seem to forget about this every time.)
I too get frustrated that people seem to forget about the arguments against your positions every time and keep bringing up positions long addressed :P
We can dig into it again, might be worth carving out some explicit time for it if you want to. Otherwise it seems fine for you to register your disagreement. My guess is it could be good to link to some of the past conversations if you have a link handy for the benefit of other readers (I don’t right now).
Here’s one.