it doesn’t seem right to me that the validity of one’s meta-ethics should depend on a contingent fact like that
I think it is a powerful secret of philosophy and AI design that all useful philosophy depends upon the philosopher(s) observing contingent facts from their sensory input stream. Philosophy can be thought of as an ultra high level machine learning technique that records the highest-level regularities of our input/output streams. And the reason I said that this is a powerful AI design principle, is that you realize that your AI can do good philosophy by looking for such regularities.
I think it is a powerful secret of philosophy and AI design that all useful philosophy depends upon the philosopher(s) observing contingent facts from their sensory input stream. Philosophy can be thought of as an ultra high level machine learning technique that records the highest-level regularities of our input/output streams. And the reason I said that this is a powerful AI design principle, is that you realize that your AI can do good philosophy by looking for such regularities.