I would be surprised if the number of readers of any given Dune sequel were greater than the number of readers of Dune itself; such would indeed constitute evidence in favor of unreasonable recentism.
Well, that’s where the sales figures comes into play and why I mentioned them. If every reader first buys Dune and only later—maybe—buys any sequel or prequel, then we would expect Dune to always outrank any of the others. To the extent that Dune does not appear on the rankings… The flow of buyers will reflect popularity.
Of course, some readers will not buy Dune and will read it a different way, but this is equally true of the sequels/prequels! Filesharing networks and libraries stock them too.
I expect that Dune is much, much more common in libraries than any of its sequels, or at least is checked out more often.
This is supported by a quick search of my local library catalog, which reveals that the library system here has zero to two copies of any given Dune sequel, nearly all of which are currently available, but six copies of Dune, only one of which is currently available.
The other library I sometimes visit appears to have zero to one copy of each Dune sequel, nearly all of which are currently available, but four copies of Dune, zero of which are available.
Obviously, this is a limited sample, but I expect that similar trends generally prevail.
Why would you think this? Besides what katydee says about libraries, I’ve gotten many SF books from my parents’ stash over the years. To the point where I had to stop myself from generalizing and rejecting your claim out of hand.
Well, that’s where the sales figures comes into play and why I mentioned them. If every reader first buys Dune and only later—maybe—buys any sequel or prequel, then we would expect Dune to always outrank any of the others. To the extent that Dune does not appear on the rankings… The flow of buyers will reflect popularity.
Of course, some readers will not buy Dune and will read it a different way, but this is equally true of the sequels/prequels! Filesharing networks and libraries stock them too.
I expect that Dune is much, much more common in libraries than any of its sequels, or at least is checked out more often.
This is supported by a quick search of my local library catalog, which reveals that the library system here has zero to two copies of any given Dune sequel, nearly all of which are currently available, but six copies of Dune, only one of which is currently available.
The other library I sometimes visit appears to have zero to one copy of each Dune sequel, nearly all of which are currently available, but four copies of Dune, zero of which are available.
Obviously, this is a limited sample, but I expect that similar trends generally prevail.
Why would you think this? Besides what katydee says about libraries, I’ve gotten many SF books from my parents’ stash over the years. To the point where I had to stop myself from generalizing and rejecting your claim out of hand.