I don’t agree with Eliezer here. I don’t think we have a deep enough understanding of consciousness to make confident predictions about what is and isn’t conscious beyond “most humans are probably conscious sometimes”.
The hypothesis that consciousness is an emergent property of certain algorithms is plausible, but only that.
If that turns out to be the case, then whether or not humans, GPT-3, or sufficiently large books are capable of consciousness depends on the details of the requirements of the algorithm.
I don’t agree with Eliezer here. I don’t think we have a deep enough understanding of consciousness to make confident predictions about what is and isn’t conscious beyond “most humans are probably conscious sometimes”.
The hypothesis that consciousness is an emergent property of certain algorithms is plausible, but only that.
If that turns out to be the case, then whether or not humans, GPT-3, or sufficiently large books are capable of consciousness depends on the details of the requirements of the algorithm.