Harry was not looking to fight a troll, he was looking to save Hermione from the troll.
Harry Potter spoke again. “We’re not going to fight the troll.
… “Great, now can we also keep Hermione Granger safe? You know,
the student framed for a murder she did not commit who needs someone
to help her?”
Further, if Hagrid had authorized a 7th year to help, they could have followed Harry’s plan of searching for Hermione and bringing her back with the most powerful wizard then available to aid and protect the search.
Hagrid could have had authorized 2 seventh years ride the broom, giving ample power to ward off a troll and protecting the supposedly helpless Harry at the same time.
Hagrid clearly prevented effective aid from riding to Hermione’s rescue, and he was the first “responsible adult” to know that she was missing. He is more responsible for the outcome than anyone but the Troll and the attacker using the troll.
Harry was not looking to fight a troll, he was looking to save Hermione from the troll.
Further, if Hagrid had authorized a 7th year to help, they could have followed Harry’s plan of searching for Hermione and bringing her back with the most powerful wizard then available to aid and protect the search.
Hagrid could have had authorized 2 seventh years ride the broom, giving ample power to ward off a troll and protecting the supposedly helpless Harry at the same time.
Hagrid clearly prevented effective aid from riding to Hermione’s rescue, and he was the first “responsible adult” to know that she was missing. He is more responsible for the outcome than anyone but the Troll and the attacker using the troll.