If its ok to kill animals, then there’s no reason to say it’s not ok to kill blicket-less humans.
I just want to point out this alternative position: Healthy (mentally and otherwise) babies can gain sufficient mental acuity/self-awareness to outstrip animals in their normal trajectory—i.e. babies become people after a while.
Although I don’t wholeheartedly agree with this position, it seems consistent. The stance that such a position would imply is that babies with severe medical conditions (debilitating birth defects, congenital diseases etc.) could be killed with parental consent, and fetuses likely to develop birth defects can be aborted, but healthy fetuses cannot be aborted, and healthy babies cannot be killed. I bring this up in particular because of your other post about the family with the severely disabled 6-year-old.
I think it becomes a little more complicated when we’re talking about situations in which we have the ability to impart self-awareness that was previously not there. On the practical level I certainly wouldn’t want to force a family to either face endless debt from an expensive procedure or a lifetime of grief from a child that can’t function in day to day tasks. It also brings up the question of whether to make animals self-aware, which is… kind of interesting but probably starting to drift off topic.
I just want to point out this alternative position: Healthy (mentally and otherwise) babies can gain sufficient mental acuity/self-awareness to outstrip animals in their normal trajectory—i.e. babies become people after a while.
Although I don’t wholeheartedly agree with this position, it seems consistent. The stance that such a position would imply is that babies with severe medical conditions (debilitating birth defects, congenital diseases etc.) could be killed with parental consent, and fetuses likely to develop birth defects can be aborted, but healthy fetuses cannot be aborted, and healthy babies cannot be killed. I bring this up in particular because of your other post about the family with the severely disabled 6-year-old.
I think it becomes a little more complicated when we’re talking about situations in which we have the ability to impart self-awareness that was previously not there. On the practical level I certainly wouldn’t want to force a family to either face endless debt from an expensive procedure or a lifetime of grief from a child that can’t function in day to day tasks. It also brings up the question of whether to make animals self-aware, which is… kind of interesting but probably starting to drift off topic.