This is exactly what I do, in every detail, except that I use −3 as my least negative target for least offensive, and I have an additional inclination to give a point for effort to what look like extensively edited and-worked on comments that have 0 net votes, even if the obvious effort was not obviously well spent.
This is exactly what I do, in every detail, except that I use −3 as my least negative target for least offensive, and I have an additional inclination to give a point for effort to what look like extensively edited and-worked on comments that have 0 net votes, even if the obvious effort was not obviously well spent.