Brian, you are defending Alcor, but you failed to disclose that you are a long standing member of Alcor’s Board of Directors. Why you concealed that important fact?
I assumed readers of this blog would recognize my name, which I wouldn’t have logged in under if my intent were concealment. I’ve been on Alcor’s board since 2004. In any case, most of what I said was objective and can be verified.
This is offtopic but I recognized your name and I just wanted to remind you that you are awesome. In addition to your research, you do a great job of accurately portraying cryonics to laymen. This presentation has helped convince at least twopeople to sign up for cryonics.
It seems to me Brian’s affiliation with Alcor is implied by the wording of the comment. I don’t think it is correct (or reasonable) to conclude that he has “concealed” anything simply from the fact that he did not explicitly mention his position there. It is publicly accessible information, after all.
However it is not clear to me why this is such an important fact to disclose in this context. Is the validity of his factual arguments dependent on who says them? Unlike Melody, he has not taken an authoritarian position based on his educational background. Brian Wowk is a PhD cryobiologist who has participated in some of the most important research on cryonics-relevant science to date.
Brian, you are defending Alcor, but you failed to disclose that you are a long standing member of Alcor’s Board of Directors. Why you concealed that important fact?
I assumed readers of this blog would recognize my name, which I wouldn’t have logged in under if my intent were concealment. I’ve been on Alcor’s board since 2004. In any case, most of what I said was objective and can be verified.
This is offtopic but I recognized your name and I just wanted to remind you that you are awesome. In addition to your research, you do a great job of accurately portraying cryonics to laymen. This presentation has helped convince at least two people to sign up for cryonics.
That presentation link has gone 404. Do you know where else it might be found, or remember the name or context of the presentation?
It seems to me Brian’s affiliation with Alcor is implied by the wording of the comment. I don’t think it is correct (or reasonable) to conclude that he has “concealed” anything simply from the fact that he did not explicitly mention his position there. It is publicly accessible information, after all.
However it is not clear to me why this is such an important fact to disclose in this context. Is the validity of his factual arguments dependent on who says them? Unlike Melody, he has not taken an authoritarian position based on his educational background. Brian Wowk is a PhD cryobiologist who has participated in some of the most important research on cryonics-relevant science to date.
It’s common knowledge, eh? At any rate I would think that most people who know who Brian Wowk is would know about the connection.