Yeah, in order to keep the problem statement clean I do think that one should specify that Paul does not have access to autobiographical memory or other self-knowledge for the duration of his time with the button making his decision. If he did, then he could use his self-knowledge to determine if he was a psychopath or not and use that information to supplement the piece of information from ‘would I choose to push the button’ to inform his prediction of whether he is indeed a psychopath and thus will be killed by pushing the button.
Yeah, in order to keep the problem statement clean I do think that one should specify that Paul does not have access to autobiographical memory or other self-knowledge for the duration of his time with the button making his decision. If he did, then he could use his self-knowledge to determine if he was a psychopath or not and use that information to supplement the piece of information from ‘would I choose to push the button’ to inform his prediction of whether he is indeed a psychopath and thus will be killed by pushing the button.