We don’t have a magical cure for depression, but if someone is depressed, they cannot make rational decisions for themselves anyway, so they cannot decide to kill themselves legitimately.
Suppose I say now, in my non-depressed state, that if I were ever to become so depressed that I wanted to die, I’d prefer that this want be fulfilled.
We cannot allow this any more than we can allow people to sold themselves to slavery as a loan guarantee.
Which doesn’t preclude allowing both. I can see benefits of allowing the latter. Or, more to the point, I can see situations where forbidding the latter is morally abhorrent. Specifically, when there is not a safety net in place that prevents people starving or otherwise suffering for the lack of finances that they should be able to acquire.
Suppose I say now, in my non-depressed state, that if I were ever to become so depressed that I wanted to die, I’d prefer that this want be fulfilled.
We cannot allow this any more than we can allow people to sold themselves to slavery as a loan guarantee.
Sure, I can see how if you didn’t like the latter then you’d dislike the former.
Which doesn’t preclude allowing both. I can see benefits of allowing the latter. Or, more to the point, I can see situations where forbidding the latter is morally abhorrent. Specifically, when there is not a safety net in place that prevents people starving or otherwise suffering for the lack of finances that they should be able to acquire.