Consider the second-order effects. If it is known that doctors regularly kill their patients in order to save other patients, would anyone ever visit a doctor unless they are sure to die otherwise? If it is known that people will take your money to save other people’s lives, would most people bother making money?
People can say “all of these aren’t good” and “I’d do it” without having to tie themselves in knots.
Consider the second-order effects. If it is known that doctors regularly kill their patients in order to save other patients, would anyone ever visit a doctor unless they are sure to die otherwise? If it is known that people will take your money to save other people’s lives, would most people bother making money?