I think it is useful for someone to tap me on the shoulder and say “Hey, this information you are consuming, its from <this source that you don’t entirely trust and have a complex causal model of>”.
Enforcing social norms to prevent scapegoating also destroys information that is valuable for accurate credit assignment and causally modelling reality. I haven’t yet found a third alternative, and until then, I’d recommend people both encourage and help people in their community to not scapegoat or lose their minds in ‘tribal instincts’ (as you put it), while not throwing away valuable information.
You can care about people while also seeing their flaws and noticing how they are hurting you and others you care about.
I think it is useful for someone to tap me on the shoulder and say “Hey, this information you are consuming, its from <this source that you don’t entirely trust and have a complex causal model of>”.
Enforcing social norms to prevent scapegoating also destroys information that is valuable for accurate credit assignment and causally modelling reality. I haven’t yet found a third alternative, and until then, I’d recommend people both encourage and help people in their community to not scapegoat or lose their minds in ‘tribal instincts’ (as you put it), while not throwing away valuable information.
You can care about people while also seeing their flaws and noticing how they are hurting you and others you care about.