If you never feel the need to say “Damn X for not damning Y” then good for you, but I think that is at least sometimes felt, and leads to judgements not being as you describe independent.
Only if the judgers care what others think of them.
There are some very real advantages to being a sociopath if you want to be a rationalist… and some very real advantages to societies that have a sufficiently great concentration of sociopaths.
If you never feel the need to say “Damn X for not damning Y” then good for you, but I think that is at least sometimes felt, and leads to judgements not being as you describe independent.
Only if the judgers care what others think of them.
There are some very real advantages to being a sociopath if you want to be a rationalist… and some very real advantages to societies that have a sufficiently great concentration of sociopaths.