Well, you’re leaving out any discussion of goals I might have other than pleasure, and how well heroin helps me achieve those goals. One difference between heroin use and painting a picture is that the latter case causes there to be a picture, for example, and I might value the existence of the picture in addition to valuing my neurochemical state.
But, sure, if I can do all the same stuff in the world as well or better while maintaining a heroin habit, then that’s not relevant.
I was hoping someone would bring that up. You’ve already given the same answer I would, though: it’s not necessarily an either/or scenario like Nozick’s “experience machine” concept, so it’s possible to have both heroin and pictures, in theory.
Well, you’re leaving out any discussion of goals I might have other than pleasure, and how well heroin helps me achieve those goals. One difference between heroin use and painting a picture is that the latter case causes there to be a picture, for example, and I might value the existence of the picture in addition to valuing my neurochemical state.
But, sure, if I can do all the same stuff in the world as well or better while maintaining a heroin habit, then that’s not relevant.
I was hoping someone would bring that up. You’ve already given the same answer I would, though: it’s not necessarily an either/or scenario like Nozick’s “experience machine” concept, so it’s possible to have both heroin and pictures, in theory.