Ooh okay. So they both don’t like wheat, but for different reasons. I had misunderstood your original statement to meant that Lindeberg would exonerate wheat. My mistake.
tldr!Lindeberg does seems to disagree with Scott about the endocrine disruption thing—unless it’s just leptin-lectin specifically we’re talking about here, and give the “toxins” idea a bit more weight than Scott does.
I stopped spending time in the paleosphere a while back and I’m not overwhelmingly proud of the epistemic purity of the parts I did frequent, so maybe you just got to see the paleosphere make their non-wretched arguments.
Yeah, amateur nutrition is chock full of quacks, and I think nutrition should be approached with almost as much skepticism as politics (which is a shame, since one’s feeding behavior is actually important).
FWIW, I’ve actually heard both the arguments that Lindenberg listed and the arguments that Scott rebutted in the paleosphere...I whole heartedly agree with Lindenberg, but I don’t particularly trust Scott’s judgement in this matter (despite otherwise thinking extremely extremely highly of him) because he’s making interpretations I wouldn’t make.
For example
Something seems to be going on with autism and schizophrenia – but most people don’t have autism or schizophrenia. The intestinal barrier seems to become more permeable with possible implications for autoimmune diseases – but most people don’t have autoimmune disease.
is just...such a weird thing for a psychiatrist to say. From my perspective Intestinal barrier problems leading to generalized inflammation and generalized mental deficiency are something to seriously worry about, especially when ADHD and depression are also linked to inflammation. From my perspective, this clearly pointing to an auto-immune-mediated deficit in general brain health, with an elevated risk of all mental problems in general. You can say that the effect is not real, but once you accept that it’s real you can’t say “oh but I’m not schizophrenic so it does not apply”, as if schizophrenic brains were so fundamentally different from healthy brains that it shouldn’t give a healthy person pause when a particular food worsens schizophrenia.
And to me,
But what none of these studies are going to do a good job ruling out is that whole grain is just funging against refined grain which is even worse.
is a big, gaping, chasming hole that Scott is treating as a minor breach. (I mean, forget refined grains, it could be funging against coke and cheetos for all we know). It’s interesting that we can look at the same data and see it so differently.
Ooh okay. So they both don’t like wheat, but for different reasons. I had misunderstood your original statement to meant that Lindeberg would exonerate wheat. My mistake.
tldr!Lindeberg does seems to disagree with Scott about the endocrine disruption thing—unless it’s just leptin-lectin specifically we’re talking about here, and give the “toxins” idea a bit more weight than Scott does.
Yeah, amateur nutrition is chock full of quacks, and I think nutrition should be approached with almost as much skepticism as politics (which is a shame, since one’s feeding behavior is actually important).
FWIW, I’ve actually heard both the arguments that Lindenberg listed and the arguments that Scott rebutted in the paleosphere...I whole heartedly agree with Lindenberg, but I don’t particularly trust Scott’s judgement in this matter (despite otherwise thinking extremely extremely highly of him) because he’s making interpretations I wouldn’t make.
For example
is just...such a weird thing for a psychiatrist to say. From my perspective Intestinal barrier problems leading to generalized inflammation and generalized mental deficiency are something to seriously worry about, especially when ADHD and depression are also linked to inflammation. From my perspective, this clearly pointing to an auto-immune-mediated deficit in general brain health, with an elevated risk of all mental problems in general. You can say that the effect is not real, but once you accept that it’s real you can’t say “oh but I’m not schizophrenic so it does not apply”, as if schizophrenic brains were so fundamentally different from healthy brains that it shouldn’t give a healthy person pause when a particular food worsens schizophrenia.
And to me,
is a big, gaping, chasming hole that Scott is treating as a minor breach. (I mean, forget refined grains, it could be funging against coke and cheetos for all we know). It’s interesting that we can look at the same data and see it so differently.