Your duplicate would initially believe itself to be a real boy made of flesh and bone.
Hmm. Yes, I suppose preserving evaluations only always preserves the correctness of those observations which are introspection. Do we have evidence for any components of consciousness that we cannot introspect upon?
To introspect is to observe your evaluations. Since introspection is observation, it is preserved; since it is about your evaluations, its correctness is preserved.
Hmm. Yes, I suppose preserving evaluations only always preserves the correctness of those observations which are introspection. Do we have evidence for any components of consciousness that we cannot introspect upon?
The issue is whether introspection would be retained.
To introspect is to observe your evaluations. Since introspection is observation, it is preserved; since it is about your evaluations, its correctness is preserved.