Vive-ut-Vivas comments on Debunking komponisto on Amanda Knox (long)

Vive-ut-Vivas 3 Feb 2010 18:59 UTC
4 points

As someone who has no interest in the case (I haven’t made any comment related to the case, nor read any of the discussions)

This appears to be the common denominator regarding people who think that Rolf has brought up game-changing information in his post.
- Wei Dai 3 Feb 2010 19:12 UTC
  −1 points
  Parent
  
  This appears to be the common denominator regarding people who think that Rolf has brought up game-changing information in his (long) post.
  
  I don’t think that he did. In fact, I can infer, without having read the discussions, that the information in Rolf’s posts are likely contained in the discussions. So the only thing I think he did was to put them in a top-level post without making a sufficiently convincing case for his position.
  - Vive-ut-Vivas 3 Feb 2010 19:15 UTC
    3 points
    Parent
    
    So the only thing I think he did was to put them in a top-level post without making a sufficiently convincing case for his position.
    
    Exactly. Therefore, it was voted down. Is this not working as intended?