Good post. I think Carroll’s PoV is correct and Sam’s is probably correct. Thinking about it, I would have phrased that one very differently, but I think there’d be zero difference on substance.
Edit: Having caught myself referencing this to explain Harris position, I amend my post to say that the way you put is actually exactly right, and the way I would have put it would at best have been a mildly confused version of the same thing.
Good post. I think Carroll’s PoV is correct and Sam’s is probably correct. Thinking about it, I would have phrased that one very differently, but I think there’d be zero difference on substance.
Edit: Having caught myself referencing this to explain Harris position, I amend my post to say that the way you put is actually exactly right, and the way I would have put it would at best have been a mildly confused version of the same thing.