Since my argument in this case is that people can be “bothered”, then yes, it would be a victory.
However, since as far as I know Eliezer didn’t claim to be “unbotherable”, that doesn’t make Eliezer wrong, at least within the context of that discussion. Eliezer didn’t disagree with me, he simply refused the legitimacy of the hypothetical.
Since my argument in this case is that people can be “bothered”, then yes, it would be a victory.
However, since as far as I know Eliezer didn’t claim to be “unbotherable”, that doesn’t make Eliezer wrong, at least within the context of that discussion. Eliezer didn’t disagree with me, he simply refused the legitimacy of the hypothetical.