I would think that it’s valid, but a smaller effect than getting taught a bundle of random things in a gratuitously unpleasant way resulting in those who have been taught in school having a deep-seated fear of learning, not to mention other forms of damage. Prior to going to school, I had an excellent attention span, even by adult standards. After graduating high school, it took two years before I could concentrate on anything, and I still suffer from brain fog.
I don’t know how common loss of attention span is, but certainly reduced interest in learning occurs extremely often.
Also, potential evidence that more damage occurs than is commonly recognized: in the modern world, we generally accept that one needs to be in one’s late teens or even early twenties to handle adult life. Yet for most of human history, people took on adult responsibilities around puberty. Part of the difference may be the world becoming more complex. But how much of it is the result of locking people up in environments with very little social or intellectual stimulation until they’re 18?
The world looks exactly like one would expect it to if school stunted intellectual and emotional maturity.
I would think that it’s valid, but a smaller effect than getting taught a bundle of random things in a gratuitously unpleasant way resulting in those who have been taught in school having a deep-seated fear of learning, not to mention other forms of damage. Prior to going to school, I had an excellent attention span, even by adult standards. After graduating high school, it took two years before I could concentrate on anything, and I still suffer from brain fog.
Hm not sure such damage commonly happens.
I don’t know how common loss of attention span is, but certainly reduced interest in learning occurs extremely often.
Also, potential evidence that more damage occurs than is commonly recognized: in the modern world, we generally accept that one needs to be in one’s late teens or even early twenties to handle adult life. Yet for most of human history, people took on adult responsibilities around puberty. Part of the difference may be the world becoming more complex. But how much of it is the result of locking people up in environments with very little social or intellectual stimulation until they’re 18?
The world looks exactly like one would expect it to if school stunted intellectual and emotional maturity.