Only if it’s a conjunctive argument. If it’s disjunctive, then only 1 step has to be right for the argument to go through.
As for the general conversation, I generally agree that consequentialism, especially the more extreme varieties lead to very weird consequences, but I’d argue that a lot of other ethical theories taken to an extreme would result in very bizarre consequences/conclusions.
Only if it’s a conjunctive argument. If it’s disjunctive, then only 1 step has to be right for the argument to go through.
As for the general conversation, I generally agree that consequentialism, especially the more extreme varieties lead to very weird consequences, but I’d argue that a lot of other ethical theories taken to an extreme would result in very bizarre consequences/conclusions.