I would say that I don’t do that, but then I’d pretty obviously be allowing the way I desire the world to be to influence my assessment of that actual state of the world. I’ll make a weaker claim—when I’m engaging conscious effort in trying to figure out how the world is and I notice myself doing it, I try to stop. Less Wrong, not Absolute Perfection.
Pretty much everyone does that almost all the time. So, is everyone blameworthy?
Of course, if everyone is blameworthy then no one is.
That’s a pretty good example of the Fallacy of Gray right there.
I would say that I don’t do that, but then I’d pretty obviously be allowing the way I desire the world to be to influence my assessment of that actual state of the world.
How do you know?
Especially since falsely holding that belief would be an example.
Lumifer wrote, “Pretty much everyone does that almost all the time.” I just figured that given what we know of heuristics and biases, there exists a charitable interpretation of the assertion that makes it true. Since the meat of the matter was about deliberate subversion of a clear-eyed assessment of the evidence, I didn’t want to get into the weeds of exactly what Lumifer meant.
I would say that I don’t do that, but then I’d pretty obviously be allowing the way I desire the world to be to influence my assessment of that actual state of the world. I’ll make a weaker claim—when I’m engaging conscious effort in trying to figure out how the world is and I notice myself doing it, I try to stop. Less Wrong, not Absolute Perfection.
That’s a pretty good example of the Fallacy of Gray right there.
How do you know?
Especially since falsely holding that belief would be an example.
Lumifer wrote, “Pretty much everyone does that almost all the time.” I just figured that given what we know of heuristics and biases, there exists a charitable interpretation of the assertion that makes it true. Since the meat of the matter was about deliberate subversion of a clear-eyed assessment of the evidence, I didn’t want to get into the weeds of exactly what Lumifer meant.