Yes, if you’ve just created it, then the criteria are meaningfully different in that case for a very limited time.
It’s not obvious to me that this is only true right after creation for a very limited time. What is supposed to change after that?
I don’t see how we’re getting off track. (Your original statement was: ‘One such “clever designer” idea is decoupling plan generation from plan execution, which really just means that the plan generator has humans as part of the initial plan executing hardware.’ If we’re discussing situations where that claim may be false, it seems to me we’re still on track.) But you shouldn’t feel obligated to reply if you don’t want to. Thanks for your replies so far, btw.
What changes is that the human sees that the AI is producing plans that try to manipulate humans. It is very likely that the human does not want the AI to produce such plans, and so applies some corrective action against it happening in future.
It’s not obvious to me that this is only true right after creation for a very limited time. What is supposed to change after that?
I don’t see how we’re getting off track. (Your original statement was: ‘One such “clever designer” idea is decoupling plan generation from plan execution, which really just means that the plan generator has humans as part of the initial plan executing hardware.’ If we’re discussing situations where that claim may be false, it seems to me we’re still on track.) But you shouldn’t feel obligated to reply if you don’t want to. Thanks for your replies so far, btw.
What changes is that the human sees that the AI is producing plans that try to manipulate humans. It is very likely that the human does not want the AI to produce such plans, and so applies some corrective action against it happening in future.