I thought being a LessWronger meant you no longer thought in terms of free will. That it’s a naive theory of human behavior, somewhat like naive physics.
Autonomy and philosophical free will are different things. Philosophical free will is the question “well, if physical laws govern how my body acts, and my brain is a component of my body, then don’t physical laws govern what choices I make?”, to which the answer is mu. One does not need volition on the level of atoms to have volition on the level of people- and volition on the level of people is autonomy.
(You will note that LW is very interested in techniques to increase one’s will, take more control over one’s goals, and so on. Those would be senseless goals for a fatalist.)
Thanks for clarifying that.
I should note that I am very interested in techniques for self-improvement, too. I am currently learning how to read. (Apparently, I never knew :( ) And also get everything organized, GTD-style. (It seems a far less daunting prospect now than when I first heard of the idea, because I’m pseudo-minimalist.)
I still am surprised at the average LWers reaction here. Probably because it’s not clear to me the nature of ‘volition on the level of people’. Not something to expect you to answer, clarifying the distinction was helpful enough.
Autonomy and philosophical free will are different things. Philosophical free will is the question “well, if physical laws govern how my body acts, and my brain is a component of my body, then don’t physical laws govern what choices I make?”, to which the answer is mu. One does not need volition on the level of atoms to have volition on the level of people- and volition on the level of people is autonomy.
(You will note that LW is very interested in techniques to increase one’s will, take more control over one’s goals, and so on. Those would be senseless goals for a fatalist.)
Thanks for clarifying that. I should note that I am very interested in techniques for self-improvement, too. I am currently learning how to read. (Apparently, I never knew :( ) And also get everything organized, GTD-style. (It seems a far less daunting prospect now than when I first heard of the idea, because I’m pseudo-minimalist.)
I still am surprised at the average LWers reaction here. Probably because it’s not clear to me the nature of ‘volition on the level of people’. Not something to expect you to answer, clarifying the distinction was helpful enough.