If multifoliaterose took the position of a advocatus diaboli, what would be wrong with that?
Multi has already refuted the opponent’s arguments, well at least Eliezer more or less refuted them for him. Now it is time to do just what Black Belt Bayesian suggested and try to fix the SIAI’s arguments for them. Because advocacy—including devil’s advocacy—is mostly bullshit.
Remind SIAI of what they are clearly doing right and also just what a good presentation of their strengths would look like—who knows, maybe it’ll spur them on and achieve in some measure just the kind of changes you desire!
So while telling the truth is maximally accurate relative to your epistemic state, concealment is deception by misguidance which is worse than the purest form of deception that is lying (falsehood). Bullshit however is not even wrong.
I don’t see how devil’s advocacy fits into this as I perceive it to be a temporary adjustment of someones mental angel to look back at one’s own position from a different point of view.
Multi has already refuted the opponent’s arguments, well at least Eliezer more or less refuted them for him. Now it is time to do just what Black Belt Bayesian suggested and try to fix the SIAI’s arguments for them. Because advocacy—including devil’s advocacy—is mostly bullshit.
Remind SIAI of what they are clearly doing right and also just what a good presentation of their strengths would look like—who knows, maybe it’ll spur them on and achieve in some measure just the kind of changes you desire!
Interesting! Levels of epistemic accuracy:
(1) Truth
(2) Concealment
(3) Falsehood
(4) Bullshit (Not even wrong)
So while telling the truth is maximally accurate relative to your epistemic state, concealment is deception by misguidance which is worse than the purest form of deception that is lying (falsehood). Bullshit however is not even wrong.
I don’t see how devil’s advocacy fits into this as I perceive it to be a temporary adjustment of someones mental angel to look back at one’s own position from a different point of view.