M. Y. Zuo comments on What is the best argument that LLMs are shoggoths?

[M. Y. Zuo]

That seems to be an argument for something more than random noise going on, but not an argument for ‘LLMs are shuggoths’?

[quetzal_rainbow]

Definition given in post:

I am looking for a discussion of evidence that the LLMs internal “true” motivation or reasoning system is very different from human, despite the human output, and that in outlying environmental conditions, very different from the training environment, it will behave very differently.

I think my example counts.