I don’t think there’s anything wrong with the topic, if it comes with a little bit of discussion along the lines of palladius’s comment below, or along the lines of “What evidence would convince us that the sanity waterline is actually rising, as opposed to just more people being raised non-religious?”
It would be very interesting to see this study in the context of trendlines for other popular sanity-correlated topics, such as belief in evolution, disbelief in ghosts, non-identification with a political party, knowledge about GMOs, etcetera, even though there are lots and lots of confounding variables.
One alone, though, without commentary about rationality, probably does not belong on LessWrong.
Indeed. At least where I am, ISTM that the main factor in determining whether one is a theist is where and when their parents grew up. (And I suspect that once you control for that, the oft-mentioned correlation between atheism and high IQ would be much weaker.) And the fact that theists are more likely to be anthropogenic global warming sceptics is likely mediated by political affiliations—right-wingers are more likely both to be theists and to be AGW sceptics—and maybe it would disappear once you control for position on the Political Compass.
I don’t think there’s anything wrong with the topic, if it comes with a little bit of discussion along the lines of palladius’s comment below, or along the lines of “What evidence would convince us that the sanity waterline is actually rising, as opposed to just more people being raised non-religious?”
It would be very interesting to see this study in the context of trendlines for other popular sanity-correlated topics, such as belief in evolution, disbelief in ghosts, non-identification with a political party, knowledge about GMOs, etcetera, even though there are lots and lots of confounding variables.
One alone, though, without commentary about rationality, probably does not belong on LessWrong.
Indeed. At least where I am, ISTM that the main factor in determining whether one is a theist is where and when their parents grew up. (And I suspect that once you control for that, the oft-mentioned correlation between atheism and high IQ would be much weaker.) And the fact that theists are more likely to be anthropogenic global warming sceptics is likely mediated by political affiliations—right-wingers are more likely both to be theists and to be AGW sceptics—and maybe it would disappear once you control for position on the Political Compass.