Might the present proposal perhaps be different in important respects from prior proposals? Might we perhaps refrain from dismissing it if we can’t even remember what the prior proposals were?
Yep, that’s a big red flag I saw. It didn’t even try to explain why this proposal wouldn’t work, and straightforwardly dismissed the research when it had potentially different properties compared to past work.
Yep, that’s a big red flag I saw. It didn’t even try to explain why this proposal wouldn’t work, and straightforwardly dismissed the research when it had potentially different properties compared to past work.